[Webkit-unassigned] [Bug 219480] New: background-image/webkit-mask-image doesn't update properly with SVG url fragments

[bugzilla-daemon at webkit.org]

https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=219480

            Bug ID: 219480
           Summary: background-image/webkit-mask-image doesn't update
                    properly with SVG url fragments
           Product: WebKit
           Version: Safari Technology Preview
          Hardware: Unspecified
                OS: Unspecified
            Status: NEW
          Severity: Normal
          Priority: P2
         Component: New Bugs
          Assignee: webkit-unassigned at lists.webkit.org
          Reporter: christopher.swasey at icloud.com

In a number of situations, a stacked SVG file + URL fragments as a background image or mask image does not seem to respect changes to the applied style after the initial render. I've reduced the issue to a number of jsfiddle examples. I've tried all examples in Safari 14, the latest Safari TP, and Chrome (to compare.) N.B.: the two Safaris fairly reliably exhibit the buggy behavior, but it can vary... rarely it'll just work as expected on page load; on the flip side, switching windows and switching back usually fixes things, but not 100% of the time.

Case 1 is the simplest. This bug seems to resolve itself fairly consistently after a window switch.

https://jsfiddle.net/9dtugq4n/

- Two classes (`foo` and `bar`) have a `-webkit-mask-image` for the same SVG, with different URL fragments (`#foo-usage` and `#bar-usage`, the `-usage` suffix originates in the webpack plugin used by the actual app I'm working on .)

- Both masks are semicircles; `foo` on the left, and `bar` on the right.

- Two divs each have classes `foo` and `black`

- A 1s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'bar black'` on both divs.

  Expected behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right for both divs

  Observed behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right only for the first div  


Case 2 does not tend to resolve itself spontaneously:

https://jsfiddle.net/9dtugq4n/1/

- Same setup, except only 1 div with `foo` and `black `. Behavior is the same for the two-div case.

- A 1s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'bar black'` on the div

- A 2s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'foo black'` on the div

  Expected behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right after one second. Then it switches back to left after another second.

  Observed behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right after one second. It does not switch back.


Case 3 is similar. I've yet to see it resolve itself in any way.

https://jsfiddle.net/9dtugq4n/3/

- Same setup, back to 2 divs.

- This time, the first div starts with the `foo` class, and the second `bar`. Both still have `black `.

- A 1s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'bar black'` on the first div

  Expected behavior: The semicircle on the second div starts on the right and stays on the right. The semicircle on the first div starts on the left and switches to the right after one second.

  Observed behavior: The semicircles have the correct initial positions, but there is no change after page load.


Case 4 shows that changing the background color avoids the bug:

https://jsfiddle.net/9dtugq4n/4/

- Same setup, 1 div.

- A 1s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'bar black'` on the div

- A 2s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'foo green'` on the div

  Expected behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right after a second. After another second, it switches back to the left and turns green.

  Observed behavior: Behaves as expected.

  Note that the _simultaneous_ background color change trick avoids the bug in all cases, but it isn't a cure... switching masks and colors, and then switching back to the first mask with the second color, doesn't work.


Case 5 demonstrates that only changing the `background-color` explicitly suffices... a combination of `background-color: currentcolor` and changing the `color` does _not_. This tends to resolve after switching windows. NOTE: this seems resolved in the latest TP.

https://jsfiddle.net/9dtugq4n/5/

- Same setup, except using `currentcolor` as the background, and toggling `color`s. 1 div.

- A 1s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'bar black'` on the div

- A 2s `setTimeout` calls `.className = 'foo green'` on the div

  Expected behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right after a second. After another second, it switches back to the left and turns green.

  Observed behavior: The semicircle switches from left to right after a second, but there is no further change.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-unassigned/attachments/20201203/64b76ffb/attachment.htm>