Alt tab display problem
Hi, I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear. I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar). Thanks Mark.
On Nov 4, 2005, at 2:54 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear.
I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar).
Thanks for the bug report. If you're going to discuss the bug here, you should probably post the bug report in Bugzilla in addition to Radar. Most of the people reading this mailing list don't have access to Radar, so it's a bit of a tease to announce a Radar bug report here. Also, I think the bug report would be a *lot* better if it included an example or test case. -- Darin
Sorry for the tease, I have updated rdar with a test case and will shortly enter one in bugzilla shortly. Thanks Mark.
On Nov 4, 2005, at 2:54 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear.
I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar).
Thanks for the bug report.
If you're going to discuss the bug here, you should probably post the bug report in Bugzilla in addition to Radar. Most of the people reading this mailing list don't have access to Radar, so it's a bit of a tease to announce a Radar bug report here.
Also, I think the bug report would be a *lot* better if it included an example or test case.
-- Darin
I already attached a test case to the one in bugzilla when I reported it: http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5566 Of course you are free to include an alternative one. André-John On 9-Nov-05, at 13:03 , Mark Thomas wrote:
Sorry for the tease, I have updated rdar with a test case and will shortly enter one in bugzilla shortly.
Thanks Mark.
On Nov 4, 2005, at 2:54 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear.
I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar).
Thanks for the bug report.
If you're going to discuss the bug here, you should probably post the bug report in Bugzilla in addition to Radar. Most of the people reading this mailing list don't have access to Radar, so it's a bit of a tease to announce a Radar bug report here.
Also, I think the bug report would be a *lot* better if it included an example or test case.
-- Darin
_______________________________________________ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@opendarwin.org http://www.opendarwin.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
The case I'm seeing is when there image and alt is there, but "Display Images when loaded" has been switched off, so its slightly different to yours, as I think it something to do with style sheets and z order'ing maybe, but the screen reader does the right thing. And the strange thing is some work and some do not. I was planning on adding one in bugzilla, but won't if its not needed if that what people want. Mark.
I already attached a test case to the one in bugzilla when I reported it:
http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5566
Of course you are free to include an alternative one.
André-John
On 9-Nov-05, at 13:03 , Mark Thomas wrote:
Sorry for the tease, I have updated rdar with a test case and will shortly enter one in bugzilla shortly.
Thanks Mark.
On Nov 4, 2005, at 2:54 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear.
I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar).
Thanks for the bug report.
If you're going to discuss the bug here, you should probably post the bug report in Bugzilla in addition to Radar. Most of the people reading this mailing list don't have access to Radar, so it's a bit of a tease to announce a Radar bug report here.
Also, I think the bug report would be a *lot* better if it included an example or test case.
-- Darin
_______________________________________________ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@opendarwin.org http://www.opendarwin.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
On Nov 9, 2005, at 12:29 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
The case I'm seeing is when there image and alt is there, but "Display Images when loaded" has been switched off, so its slightly different to yours, as I think it something to do with style sheets and z order'ing maybe, but the screen reader does the right thing. And the strange thing is some work and some do not.
I was planning on adding one in bugzilla, but won't if its not needed if that what people want.
If there's any doubt in your mind about whether it's a duplicate, please do file a new bug. Make it as clear as possible, and others working on the WebKit project will try to determine if it's a duplicate or not. There's no shame in filing something that does turn out to be a duplicate. John Sullivan often says, "A well-written bug report is always worthwhile." -- Darin
Hi, Ok entered, as believe my case not to be the same due that my images are present and sometimes works and sometimes not :-( http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5753 reporting this actual problem, and I have also put the rdar number there as well, as well as updating rdar as well. Although wondering now if I should take a look myself as have src on my machine and built, any idea which file this problem might be ? Thanks Mark.
On Nov 9, 2005, at 12:29 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
The case I'm seeing is when there image and alt is there, but "Display Images when loaded" has been switched off, so its slightly different to yours, as I think it something to do with style sheets and z order'ing maybe, but the screen reader does the right thing. And the strange thing is some work and some do not.
I was planning on adding one in bugzilla, but won't if its not needed if that what people want.
If there's any doubt in your mind about whether it's a duplicate, please do file a new bug. Make it as clear as possible, and others working on the WebKit project will try to determine if it's a duplicate or not.
There's no shame in filing something that does turn out to be a duplicate.
John Sullivan often says, "A well-written bug report is always worthwhile."
-- Darin
Hi, Ok also added test case was slight confused as bugzilla only asks for that after it is entered. Its the same test case which I uploaded into rdar so both systems should be level. Thanks Mark. --------------------------------------------------- Hi, Ok entered, as believe my case not to be the same due that my images are present and sometimes works and sometimes not :-( http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5753 reporting this actual problem, and I have also put the rdar number there as well, as well as updating rdar as well. Although wondering now if I should take a look myself as have src on my machine and built, any idea which file this problem might be ? Thanks Mark.
On Nov 9, 2005, at 12:29 PM, Mark Thomas wrote:
The case I'm seeing is when there image and alt is there, but "Display Images when loaded" has been switched off, so its slightly different to yours, as I think it something to do with style sheets and z order'ing maybe, but the screen reader does the right thing. And the strange thing is some work and some do not.
I was planning on adding one in bugzilla, but won't if its not needed if that what people want.
If there's any doubt in your mind about whether it's a duplicate, please do file a new bug. Make it as clear as possible, and others working on the WebKit project will try to determine if it's a duplicate or not.
There's no shame in filing something that does turn out to be a duplicate.
John Sullivan often says, "A well-written bug report is always worthwhile."
-- Darin
Hi, I added the same issue the other day in bugzilla: http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5566 I should note that Omniweb doesn't have this issue, but Safari does. Then again Omniweb seems to be using its own version of webcore. Andre On 4-Nov-05, at 17:54 , Mark Thomas wrote:
Hi, I thought I'd report up that if there are images are using the alt tags, and you overlay the images using the visibility to control which appears while the right image is displayed, but when show images has been switched off, the alt tag's won't appear.
I've entered rdar://4330277 for this, its not hugely big for us, as we are only doing this to check that we have alt'ed the images for accessibility reasons, screen reader will read it correctly when not crashing constantly though (that's under another rdar).
Thanks Mark.
_______________________________________________ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@opendarwin.org http://www.opendarwin.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
participants (3)
-
André-John Mas
-
Darin Adler
-
Mark Thomas